Skip to content

From 3 videos

Can I lose weight without counting macros?

Answered by Maggie Topham and WarriorBabe's coaches · Updated

The short answer

Yes, according to the show, though it helps to track something. Maggie Topham lost 60 pounds in menopause after she stopped tracking everything and tracked only protein, about 150 grams a day. Other women, like Erica, found that learning macros properly was what finally brought results after years of eating healthy without measuring.

Hear it answered

Tap play to start right where it's answered. It keeps playing while you browse.

  1. Maggie on dropping full tracking for protein only and losing 60 pounds in menopause

    Plays from 5:33 · Video: Losing 60 Pounds in Menopause by Quitting Cardio at 52

  2. Maggie on why tracking just protein gave her freedom and balanced the rest

    Plays from 2:37 · Video: Quit Cardio, Lift and Track Protein: Getting Lean at 51

  3. Erica on how finally understanding macros changed her results

    Plays from 2:25 · Video: Learning Macros and Lifting Smarter: Erica's Story

The full answer

Maggie's story is the clearest case for dropping full macro tracking. She describes years of obsessive tracking and eating as little as possible, at one point about 800 calories a day, while the weight wouldn't budge. The shift she calls almost stupidly simple was to stop tracking everything and track only protein. She says it gave her far more freedom, and that once her protein was in, other things started to balance out naturally. Today she eats around 2,500 calories a day with over 150 grams of protein, including rice, potatoes and fruit, and says she is the leanest she has ever been.

Notice what she didn't do: she didn't stop paying attention. Protein was the anchor, and she paired it with strength training as her foundation. She points out that women can lose up to 1% of muscle mass a year and that protein is critical to slow or reverse this. She also credits more muscle and less stress with changes in her metabolism and hormones; that is her experience, and if menopause symptoms are part of your picture, talk it through with your doctor.

Erica's story adds the other side. Before joining WarriorBabe she ate what she thought was healthy, chicken, rice, vegetables and fruit, but never measured anything. She says understanding macros and the science behind each one was one of the biggest changes for her.

So the honest answer is that you don't have to log every gram forever, but guessing is usually what's been keeping you stuck. If full tracking has made you anxious, starting with protein alone is a simpler path the show describes working. If you've never measured at all, learning what's actually on your plate may be the missing piece. Either way, it's the plan, not you.

From WarriorBabe's coaches (how we write our answers). For education, not medical advice: talk to your doctor about your own health.

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    Should I track macros in grams or percentages?

    Track in grams. Nikkiey explains that percentage goals shift whenever your total calories shift. A 40% protein goal is a different amount on a 1,600-calorie day than on a 2,100-calorie day. Fixed gram targets, like 150 grams of protein, give you a stable number to build meals around, measure progress against and troubleshoot.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    Should my macros be different for losing fat than for building muscle?

    Yes. Nikkiey Stott says fat loss and muscle building need different game plans. Protein holds steady or goes up in both, around one gram per pound or more, while calories move: a slow, gradual deficit to lose fat, and a slow climb into a surplus, mostly from carbs, to build muscle.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    How long does it take to get good at tracking macros?

    Expect a learning curve of about three to four months, with tracking feeling noticeably easier somewhere between six months and a year. Nikkiey's first planning sessions took up to an hour and a half; years later she logs a full day in about two minutes. Some women, like guest Valerie, hit their numbers within two weeks.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    Do women over 50 need different macros than younger women to lose weight?

    Yes and no. Nikkiey Stott says a woman over 50 can't copy a 30-year-old's macros, because your numbers should fit your body, your stats and your goals. But she also says postmenopausal women don't need a special formula like higher fat and lower carb. The priority is eating enough to fuel recovery.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    How many meals a day should I eat when tracking macros?

    Nikkiey Stott's guidance is to eat at least five meals a day while tracking macros, and that count includes your pre- and post-workout meals. Eating fewer meals is fine as long as you still hit your macros and spread your protein across every meal, so cravings don't take over the rest of your day.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    Do I have to track macros forever?

    No. Nikkiey is clear that you don't have to track macros for the rest of your life. Tracking and weighing your food is a temporary, educational phase that teaches you what real portions of protein, carbs and fat look like. Do it consistently for a couple of years and it becomes second nature.

    Read the answer →

Watch or listen in full

More on this topic →

Talk to a coach

21,800+ women coached

Apply now