From 4 episodes and 1 video
How can I tell if fitness and nutrition advice is backed by science?
Answered by Nikkiey Stott and WarriorBabe's coaches · Updated
The short answer
Start by questioning the source. Nikkiey Stott asks whether advice is based on scientific research or is a trend or marketing trying to sell you something. Lean on reliable sources like a well-qualified coach, scientific studies or a nutritionist, and be wary of anything extreme, like cutting entire food groups or replacing meals with supplements or juice.
Hear it answered
Tap play to start right where it's answered. It keeps playing while you browse.
Nikkiey on checking whether advice comes from research, trends or marketing
Plays from 24:39 · Ep. 185: Do Carbs or Fat Make You Gain Weight? Diet Myths Debunked
Nikkiey's four checks: question the source, balance, your body, avoid extremes
Plays from 25:43 · Ep. 185: Do Carbs or Fat Make You Gain Weight? Diet Myths Debunked
Nikkiey on why she won't trust trainers who don't live the lifestyle
Plays from 5:01 · Ep. 60: When Family Doesn't Support Your Weight Loss Goals
Nikkiey's rule: only take advice from people far ahead of you in that area
Plays from 14:12 · Ep. 348: How to Stop Fearing Judgment at the Gym After 40
Nikkiey on spotting fitness accounts that leave you insecure instead of inspired
Plays from 21:34 · Ep. 27: Starting a Fitness Journey: 6 Things Women Should Know
The full answer
On Ep. 185, Nikkiey offers four checks for nutrition advice: question the source, focus on balance, listen to your body and avoid extremes. Balance means eating patterns that include protein, fat and carbs before you decide to cut something out or try a detox. She points out that your liver, kidneys and digestive system already work together to detoxify your body, which is why cleanses and juice-only days are red flags. Listening to your body matters too, because what works for your sister or best friend may not work for you.
The show adds a second filter: who is giving the advice. On Ep. 60, Nikkiey says she finds it hard to trust trainers who tell you how to eat and train but aren't living the lifestyle themselves. Take advice from people who have been on the journey and have the results you want. On Ep. 348 she narrows this further: she only takes advice from people far more successful than her in that specific area, like a woman who has built a strong, toned body and kept it for years. Opinions from passersby go through a filter.
Social media needs its own check. On Ep. 27, Nikkiey warns that some fitness gurus train six days a week for two hours or eat at unusual ratios, and that isn't the right approach for most women. Some simply say the wrong things. Notice how you think and talk about yourself after following an account. If it leaves you ashamed or comparing yourself negatively, that's a sign it isn't serving you.
These episodes give a practical filter rather than a guide to reading research. If you're unsure, the advice is to get support from a coach who is well equipped in this work. Confusion usually comes from the noise, not from you.
From WarriorBabe's coaches (how we write our answers). For education, not medical advice: talk to your doctor about your own health.
Part of
Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture →Women also ask
More questions →
Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Do carbs make you gain weight?
No. Nikkiey explains that carbs on their own don't make you gain fat. Eating more calories than your body burns does, whether those calories come from carbs, fat or protein. Carbs are stored as glycogen, which holds about three grams of water per gram, so the scale can rise temporarily without any fat gain.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Does eating fat make you fat?
No. Nikkiey explains that eating fat doesn't make you fat; eating too many calories, or so few that your body holds on to fat, does. Dietary fat supports hormone production, brain function and nutrient absorption, and healthy fats like avocados, nuts, seeds and olive oil fit into a fat-loss plan. Trans fats are the ones to avoid.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Do I need to detox or do a cleanse to lose weight?
No. Nikkiey explains that your liver, kidneys and digestive system already filter out and eliminate toxins, so juice cleanses and detox supplements aren't needed. Detox diets usually mean severe calorie restriction, which can lead to nutrient deficiencies, muscle loss and a slowed metabolism. A balanced diet and steady daily habits work better.
Read the answer →
Watch or listen in full
More on this topic →
25 minStarting a Fitness Journey: 6 Things Women Should Know
Episode 27 · Mar 10, 2023
30 minDo Carbs or Fat Make You Gain Weight? Diet Myths Debunked
Episode 185 · Aug 30, 2024
28 minHow to Stop Fearing Judgment at the Gym After 40
Episode 348 · Mar 30, 2026
Free Body Transformation Assessment
Done with diets? Good. So are we.
Keto, fasting, 1,200 calories, Monday restarts. You did the work, and the diets let you down. We'll help you eat in a way you can keep for life.
- No foods off-limits
- Eat more and still see results
- A plan built for the long term
21,800+ women transformed