Skip to content

From 4 videos

How lean is too lean for a woman?

Answered by Nikkiey Stott, Maggie Topham and WarriorBabe's coaches · Updated

The short answer

You're too lean when your body stops running its basic functions. The WarriorBabe Show gives no body fat number. Nikkiey Stott and Maggie Topham point to signals: losing your period, constant fatigue, irritability, low energy and losing muscle. Ida Bergfoth adds that competition-level body fat isn't healthy or sustainable, especially for women.

Hear it answered

Tap play to start right where it's answered. It keeps playing while you browse.

  1. Nikkiey on losing her period for eight months while getting stage-lean

    Plays from 10:53 · Video: Dieting Too Long? Effects on Muscle, Bones and Metabolism

  2. Ida Bergfoth and a coach on why competition body fat isn't healthy for women

    Plays from 1:04 · Video: What Happens to Your Body After a Bodybuilding Competition?

  3. Maggie on mistaking a lost period for proof she was working hard enough

    Plays from 0:34 · Video: What Should Women in Their 30s Do Now to Feel Good at 50?

  4. Nikkiey on fatigue, irritability and missed periods as warning signs

    Plays from 10:15 · Video: Dieting Too Long? Effects on Muscle, Bones and Metabolism

The full answer

Nikkiey's own story is the clearest marker. While preparing for her first bodybuilding competition, she lost her period for eight months and thought it was normal. She explains that her body fat was extremely low and she wasn't eating enough to support basic functions, so her body stopped prioritizing reproduction and put its energy toward survival. She describes undernourishment suppressing the hypothalamus, the part of the brain that regulates the menstrual cycle. Maggie Topham tells a similar story from her 30s: near-daily cardio, eating as little as she could, a lost period she took as proof she was working hard enough. Looking back, she sees it as slowly draining her body of what it needed long term. If your cycle has stopped or changed, bring that to your doctor.

Nikkiey lists other signals that you've pushed too far or dieted too long:

She notes that some hunger is expected during fat loss, but the rest aren't normal. They're your body telling you to change the plan.

  • Ongoing fatigue, low energy and irritability
  • Nutrient deficiencies
  • Losing muscle, so you get smaller but look "skinny fat"
  • A slowing metabolism and plateaus even though you're eating very little

On a bodybuilding episode, former competitor Ida Bergfoth and a WarriorBabe coach agree that stage-level body fat isn't healthy to hold, especially for women. It's so extreme it can't be maintained, and Ida says her body took years to feel normal after competing. Maggie offers a useful gut check: could you live this way for the next 20 to 30 years? If not, you're borrowing from your future.

The point underneath all of it: Nikkiey says the goal was never to get as skinny as possible. It's to build lean muscle so you get stronger, lose fat and change how your body looks and feels, on a plan you can keep.

From WarriorBabe's coaches (how we write our answers). For education, not medical advice: talk to your doctor about your own health.

Part of

Women's Health & Aging →

Women also ask

More questions →
  • Women's Health & Aging

    Does strength training help bone density in menopause?

    Yes. Nikkiey explains that strength training puts stress on your bones, which triggers them to rebuild stronger and denser, raising bone mineral density and lowering osteoporosis risk as estrogen drops in menopause. On the show, she and guest Sal Di Stefano agree that walking and cardio don't come close to resistance training for bone.

    Read the answer →

  • Women's Health & Aging

    Can I strength train after a knee or hip replacement?

    Yes, according to several women on The WarriorBabe Show who did it. Johanna lifts three days a week after two total knee replacements and says she has no programming limitations. Peggy started about four to five months after her surgeries with one modified session a week. Follow your surgeon's guidance and modify every movement.

    Read the answer →

  • Women's Health & Aging

    Does lifting weights help your mental health?

    Yes. On The WarriorBabe Show, Nikkiey explains that lifting gives the stress your body carries somewhere to go, triggers endorphins she calls the brain's natural antidepressants, and builds confidence every time you lift heavier. She also cautions that not every way of exercising is good for your mind, especially when your training is driven by guilt.

    Read the answer →

Watch or listen in full

More on this topic →

Free Body
Transformation Assessment

Apply now