Skip to content

Video4 minWith Nikkiey Stott

Keto vs Weight Watchers vs Macros for Women Over 40

Chapters

This video is part ofDiets, Fasting & Diet Culture133 lessons · where to start, common questions and more

In this video

If you've cut carbs, counted points or skipped meals and watched the results fade, Nikkiey Stott explains that the problem isn't you. It's how these diets are built. Keto, Weight Watchers and intermittent fasting all work at first because they get you eating fewer calories. None of them teach you how to eat for the rest of your life, so the weight comes back.

Nikkiey's alternative is balancing your macros: protein to build muscle and keep you full, carbs to fuel training and recovery, and fats to support hormones and brain function. She makes the case that carbs aren't the enemy. They give you the energy to train and build muscle, and more muscle means a faster metabolism. The key is knowing how much to eat, not cutting them out.

She finishes with a simple sample day of eating with eggs, chicken, salmon, rice, quinoa, yogurt and almonds. No food groups are cut out, and there's room for pizza, chocolate or wine when you adjust your macros.

Key takeaways

  • Fad diets are designed for short-term weight loss, and if you can't eat that way for the rest of your life, the weight will come back.
  • Keto drops weight fast mostly through water rather than fat, which is why the weight returns as soon as you eat carbs again.
  • Weight Watchers points let you eat low-calorie junk food and stay on plan, but they don't teach you nutrient balance.
  • Intermittent fasting can help some people control calories, but without the right macros you won't see the right results, fasting or not.
  • Protein builds muscle and keeps you full, carbs fuel your workouts and recovery, and fats support hormones and brain function.
  • Instead of eliminating carbs, learn how much to eat, because they give you the energy to train hard and build the muscle that speeds up your metabolism.
  • A sustainable fat loss day can be as simple as eggs, whole grain toast and avocado, then chicken with quinoa and vegetables, then salmon with jasmine rice and salad, with Greek yogurt, a protein shake or almonds as snacks.
  • You can fit foods you love like pizza, chocolate and wine into your plan by adjusting your macros.

Questions answered

Why does the weight come back after keto?

Nikkiey explains that keto cuts out carbs almost entirely, so the fast weight loss is mostly water weight, not fat. The second you eat carbs again, the weight comes back.

What's wrong with Weight Watchers points?

According to Nikkiey, Weight Watchers makes you obsess over points without teaching you about actual nutrient balance. You can eat low-calorie junk food and still be on plan while your body isn't getting what it needs.

Does intermittent fasting work for fat loss?

Nikkiey says shortening your eating window can help some people control calories. If you're not eating the right macros, though, you won't see the right results whether you fast or not.

Do you need carbs to lose fat?

Yes, in Nikkiey's view. Carbs give you the energy to train hard and build muscle, and more muscle means a faster metabolism. The key is knowing how much to eat, not eliminating them.

What does a sustainable fat loss meal plan look like?

Nikkiey's example is scrambled eggs, whole grain toast and avocado for breakfast, grilled chicken, quinoa and roasted vegetables for lunch, and salmon, jasmine rice and a big salad for dinner. Snacks are Greek yogurt with fruit, a protein shake or a handful of almonds.

Can you eat pizza, chocolate or wine and still lose fat?

Nikkiey says you can fit in the foods you love, including pizza, chocolate and wine, by adjusting your macros. She calls that the reason this approach works long term.

Ask Nikkiey

Questions this video helps answer, with what Nikkiey says across everything WarriorBabe teaches.

  • Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture

    Why does the weight come back after keto?

    Most of the fast weight you lose on keto is water, not fat. Nikkiey explains that carbs hold on to water in your body, so cutting them drops the scale quickly. The moment you eat carbs again, that water returns. Because you can't avoid carbs forever, the weight comes back.

    Read the answer →

Full transcript

Nikkiey: If you're tired of cutting carbs, starving yourself, or following diet plans that work for a little while and then leave you stuck, this video is for you. Keto, Weight Watchers, fasting, they all promise results, but the reason they fail isn't you. It's the way these diets are set up. So today, I'm breaking down why fad diets don't last, how you can eat carbs, enjoy life, and still lose fat, and what a real sustainable fat loss plan actually looks like.

Let's get into it. Why most diets fail. Here's the problem with fad diets. They're designed for short-term weight loss, not long-term success. They all work at first because they make you eat fewer calories, but they don't teach you how to eat properly for life. Let's break them down.

Number one, keto. It cuts out carbs almost entirely, so yes, you lose weight fast because you're dropping water weight, not fat. The second you eat carbs again, the weight comes back.

Number two, Weight Watchers. It makes you obsess over points, but doesn't teach you about actual nutrient balance. You can eat low-calorie junk food and still technically be on plan, but your body isn't getting what it needs.

Number three, intermittent fasting. It works by shortening your eating window, which can help some people control calories, but if you're not eating the right macros, fasting or not, you won't see the right results.

Bottom line, extreme restrictions equal temporary results. If you can't eat this way for the rest of your life, the weight will come back.

How macros actually work. Instead of cutting out entire food groups, let's talk about what actually works: macros. Macros equal protein plus carbs plus fats. Every single food you eat is made up of these three things, and instead of fearing them, you need to balance them properly for fat loss and muscle gain. Protein builds muscle and keeps you full. Carbs fuel your workouts and help with recovery. And fats support hormones and brain function. When you get the right amount of each, your body burns fat efficiently without extreme restrictions. You can eat the foods you love without guilt. You just learn how to portion them right.

Here's why you need carbs for fat loss. Carbs are not the enemy. In fact, cutting carbs hurts your fat loss in the long run. Here's why. Carbs give you the energy to train hard and build muscle. More muscle equals faster metabolism, which means you burn fat even when you're not working out. Low carb diets make you lose water weight, not body fat, which is why the weight comes back so fast when you start eating carbs again. If you want to get leaner and stronger, you need carbs. The key is knowing how much to eat, not eliminating them.

Here's what a real fat loss meal plan looks like, one you can actually stick to. For breakfast, scrambled eggs, whole grain toast, and an avocado. For lunch, grilled chicken, quinoa, and roasted vegetables. For dinner, salmon, jasmine rice, and a big salad. And snacks in between: Greek yogurt with fruit, a protein shake, a handful of almonds. This is just an example, and it's nothing crazy. There's no cutting out food groups, just balanced nutrition that fuels your body. And the best part, you can fit in the foods that you love, pizza, chocolate, wine, by adjusting your macros. That's why this works long term.

At the end of the day, you don't need another diet. You need a plan that actually fits your life. If you're tired of restrictive eating, counting calories, or fearing carbs, focus on balancing your macros instead. It's the only way to lose fat, build muscle, and actually keep your results.

If this helped you, hit the like button, subscribe for more no BS fitness advice, and drop a comment below. Let's build a strong, lean body for life, not just for a quick fix.

Best of Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture

All 133 →

Free Body
Transformation Assessment

Apply now