Skip to content

From 2 episodes and 2 videos

Should I plan my food ahead or log it as I eat?

Answered by Nikkiey Stott and Maggie Topham · Updated

The short answer

Plan ahead. WarriorBabe's coaches recommend logging your food the night before or first thing in the morning, before you eat. Logging as you go usually leaves you at 9 p.m. with protein, carbs or fat left to hit and nothing you can do about it except macro hoard. Planning first lets you adjust while there's still time.

Hear it answered

Tap play to start right where it's answered. It keeps playing while you browse.

  1. Nikkiey on the tracking-as-you-go mistake and how planning the night before changed it

    Plays from 5:59 · Ep. 55: How to Start Counting Macros Without Getting Frustrated

  2. Why logging as you go leads to macro hoarding, and when advanced trackers can check in

    Plays from 6:18 · Ep. 54: Goals vs Systems: How to Stay Consistent With Fat Loss

  3. Maggie on logging first, eating second, so you can fix the day before it's over

    Plays from 1:50 · Video: 7 Simple Daily Habits for Losing Fat After Menopause

  4. Planning tomorrow's meals tonight to avoid the end-of-day scramble for protein and carbs

    Plays from 0:35 · Video: How to Plan a 150g Protein, 2,000 Calorie Day in Advance

The full answer

Nikkiey has lived both sides of this. On Ep. 55 she describes logging each meal after eating it and constantly landing over on carbs and fats and short on protein, often because foods she assumed had protein were mostly fat or carbs. She was frustrated enough to want to quit, until she started planning every meal the night before. She calls that switch a game changer. On Ep. 54 she puts it bluntly: tracking as you go sets you up for failure, because you hit the end of the day with 20 grams of protein, 50 of carbs and 30 of fat left and end up macro hoarding, which leaves you feeling awful and sleeping badly.

In Maggie's daily habits video she calls after-the-fact tracking a post-mortem. Log first, eat second. When the day is mapped out before it starts, you can see that dinner needs more protein or swap a snack before it's too late. In her 2,000-calorie planning video Nikkiey shows how the night-before plan works in practice: about 20 minutes to plan, meals portioned into containers, and the next day you just pull them from the fridge.

A few habits make planning easier:

  • Cook your protein for the week on Sunday so hitting your target isn't a nightly negotiation.
  • Rotate the same two or three breakfasts to take one meal off your decision load.

There is one nuance. On Ep. 54 Nikkiey says that once tracking is a solid habit, more experienced trackers can go half the day without logging, then check in to see what's left. That's a later stage. Start by building the habit of planning ahead.

From WarriorBabe's coaches (how we write our answers). For education, not medical advice: talk to your doctor about your own health.

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    How many meals a day should I eat when tracking macros?

    Nikkiey Stott's guidance is to eat at least five meals a day while tracking macros, and that count includes your pre- and post-workout meals. Eating fewer meals is fine as long as you still hit your macros and spread your protein across every meal, so cravings don't take over the rest of your day.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    Should I only track protein when I first start counting macros?

    Mostly, yes. Nikkiey suggests focusing only on hitting your protein number for the first couple of weeks, then gradually adding carbs and fats to what you track. That doesn't mean eating only protein. Keep eating carbs and fats from good-quality food, you just aren't putting much emphasis on their numbers yet.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    How close do I need to get to my macro targets?

    Nikkiey's target is within plus or minus five grams of each macro: protein, fat and carbs. Land there and you've nailed your macros for the day. You don't have to hit it every day, especially in your first few weeks; hitting your targets most of the time is what counts.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    Can I still eat treats while tracking macros?

    Yes. Across The WarriorBabe Show, Nikkiey's position is that treats work when they fit your numbers and stay the minority of what you eat, roughly 80% quality food and 20% fun food. She has two to four pieces of dark chocolate most nights, and members fit in cookies, pizza and ice cream swaps while losing fat.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    How often should I adjust my macros?

    Give new macros at least three to four weeks before changing anything, one WarriorBabe coach says, and often longer. Some women run the same numbers for eight to 16 weeks. Adjust when progress actually stalls, using small cuts of about 125 to 200 calories from carbs and fats. In maintenance, Nikkiey raises intake every one to two weeks.

    Read the answer →

  • Macros & Macro Tracking

    Do I have to track macros forever?

    No. Nikkiey is clear that you don't have to track macros for the rest of your life. Tracking and weighing your food is a temporary, educational phase that teaches you what real portions of protein, carbs and fat look like. Do it consistently for a couple of years and it becomes second nature.

    Read the answer →

Watch or listen in full

More on this topic →

Get a free Body Transformation Assessment

21,800+ women coached

Apply now