Chapters
In this video
You're showing up, you're eating well, and nothing is changing. In this short collection of highlights from The WarriorBabe Show, Nikkiey Stott explains how to tell whether you're actually in a plateau. The clearest sign is consistent effort with no results for four to six weeks. That shows up as no change in your progress photos, stalled strength or endurance, and measurements, especially your waist, that won't budge, all while you're honestly consistent with training.
Nikkiey then explains why so many women who spend an hour or two on the treadmill, elliptical and StairMaster every week look the same a year later. She says the calorie numbers on those machines have virtually nothing to do with anything, and that your body adapts to high-calorie-burning, low-muscle workouts by slowing down its metabolism. She shares that this was her, too.
Strength training works differently. It asks your body for strength and muscle, and Nikkiey explains that building that muscle is what speeds up your metabolism and supports fat loss. Using weights, resistance bands or bodyweight creates micro tears in muscle fibers that repair and grow back stronger. That is how you build muscle, and in her words, that is all being toned really means. It won't make you bulky.
Key takeaways
- The most obvious sign of a plateau is consistent effort with no results, and you need to be honest with yourself about how consistent you really are.
- Take progress photos, because no visible change over four to six weeks is one of the clearest ways to know you've stalled.
- If you've used the same challenging weight for about four weeks and adding five to ten pounds means you can't finish your prescribed sets or reps, you may be in a plateau.
- Only call it a plateau when you're consistent with training, such as hitting four to five strength sessions a week.
- If you take measurements, watch your waist in particular, since most women lose body fat from the top down first.
- Small nutrition adjustments can help break a plateau, but the right adjustment depends on the individual and her lifestyle, which is where a coach helps.
- Don't rely on the calorie burn numbers on cardio machines, which Nikkiey says have virtually nothing to do with anything.
- Strength training with weights, bands or bodyweight builds muscle, which is what being toned means, and it will not make you bulky.
Questions answered
How do I know if I'm in a fitness plateau?
Nikkiey says the clearest sign is consistent effort with no results for four to six weeks. That includes no change in progress photos, stalled strength or endurance, and measurements like your waist not moving, while you're truly consistent with training.
How long should I wait before deciding I'm in a plateau?
Nikkiey uses a window of four to six weeks. If you're consistent and see no changes in progress photos or measurements over that time, you may be in a plateau.
Why do people who do hours of cardio still look the same?
Nikkiey explains that the body adapts to high-calorie-burning workouts that require very little muscle by slowing down its metabolism. They may lose some weight, but it isn't conducive to building muscle.
Are the calories burned on cardio machines accurate?
Nikkiey says the calorie numbers on those machines have virtually nothing to do with anything, so they're not a useful measuring tool.
What does getting toned actually mean?
According to Nikkiey, toned simply means building muscle. Strength training breaks down muscle fibers so they grow back stronger and bigger, which is how you get a lean, toned body.
Will strength training make me bulky?
Nikkiey says that fear is not true. Strength training is how you build muscle and get toned, and it supports your overall health, strength and metabolism.
Full transcript
Nikkiey: What is going on, everybody? Welcome to this bonus episode featuring a collection of the best moments from The WarriorBabe Show during Season 1. Get ready, because Season 2 is launching on February 5th, and this season will be packed with brand new, complete episodes. For now, tune in to this bonus one.
Consistent effort with no results. That is how you know you're on a plateau. If for four to six weeks you're not seeing these changes reflect in your progress photos, and if you're not taking progress photos, you need to be taking progress photos. But let's say you're not seeing progress in the progress photos, and some things have stalled elsewhere. This is how you would know you're in a plateau.
The second thing that marries with the first one is that you've stalled strength or endurance gains. You're stalling in the amount of weight that you can lift. If you're not progressing in the weights that you lift, or let's say you're focusing on some type of endurance running and those levels are pretty much stalled at this point, you're not experiencing progress with it, and you're consistent with your training. I just need to add this in there: you're consistent with your training. You're hitting your four to five strength training sessions a week. You're doing whatever is in alignment with the endurance training that you're doing, if you're doing it, and you're consistent with that. Then you might be in a plateau.
What I mean specifically speaking to weights is, let's say for the last four weeks you have been using the same weight each time, and that is a challenge to you. And I would say going up five to ten pounds is too much of a challenge to you, where you can't finish the prescribed sets and/or reps. This might be a point where you're experiencing a plateau, and the littlest adjustment to nutrition can help with that. That's why it's really good to have a coach on your side.
The last point I want to make on how to know you're in a plateau is diving a little bit deeper into point one, where I talked about progress photos. Maybe you're somebody who's taking measurements and you're using the measuring tape. Some clients do this and some clients don't. It's not necessary; it depends on all of the things. But let's say you're taking measurements with the measuring tape, and you're doing your waist, your hips, your biceps, all of these things, but they're not changing in those four to six weeks, especially your waist. If you're decreasing weight and you're overweight, then you should see changes in your waist. If you're decreasing body fat, you may see changes in specific areas of your body. People lose body fat in different areas. All women do, but the majority of women will lose it from the top down first. And let's say in those four to six weeks we're not seeing much movement in terms of measurements over that time. These are all possibilities of you being in a plateau.
But the first one I spoke to is probably the most obvious one: consistent effort with no results. You're being consistent. You're honest with your consistency. And we're still not seeing any progress. So then we would make some adjustments. I'm not going to dive into adjustments, because we're just speaking to when you know you're in a plateau and what you can do to overcome it. Adjustments would be very individual to the person: whatever that person may be experiencing, why we're in a plateau, what's going on with lifestyle, X, Y and Z. There are many factors that could be at play. But I just wanted to give you these strategies in terms of how to know you're in it. These are the ones to know you're in it.
With strength workouts, your workouts don't really burn that many calories, but those workouts require strength and muscle. Now your body is like, let's build this muscle, and we can be less efficient with calories so that you can build that muscle, which is what will speed up your metabolism and help aid in the fat loss that you want to see with your body.
You see all these people who routinely go into the gym. Maybe you can picture the people on the cardio equipment when you walk into the gym, and you're like, oh my God, I see this person all the time doing the same thing every week. They're in there for one to two hours doing cardio on all different cardio equipment. They go from the treadmill to the elliptical to the StairMaster. And they may be paying such fine-tuned attention to how many calories they eat during the day. Maybe they're trying to eat better. They're like, I'm counting calories, I'm paying attention, I'm eating better. And now I'm going in and I'm watching the equipment tell me I'm burning X, Y and Z. So they're watching that during their workout sessions, and they're using that measuring tool built into the machines: I ate 1,800 calories today, and I burned 600 calories on this treadmill. Awesome.
That number on those machines has virtually nothing to do with anything, okay? What those people on those machines don't realize, or maybe this was you, and this was definitely me, so you're not alone if this is you, and I'm hoping I'm going to make some light bulbs go off in your brain today, is that over the long period of time they've been doing the same exact thing, they've actually been slowing down their metabolism by conserving calories for that activity. You train your body to get better at what you're teaching it to do, or what your workouts are doing. So if your workouts are high-calorie burning and require very little muscle, then your body learns to adapt to that workout by slowing down its metabolism.
Guys, that's probably why you've seen these people in the gym every single week for the last 52 weeks, and they look virtually the same. Maybe they've lost some weight, okay? But it's not conducive to building muscle.
Strength training is essential for building muscle, increasing strength, and so, so much more. By using resistance to target specific muscles, such as weightlifting, resistance band training or bodyweight exercises, you're causing micro tears in the muscle fibers, which then repair and grow back stronger and bigger. This is how you build muscle mass. This is how you increase muscle mass, which is what being toned means.
Side note, I freaking hate that word toned, you guys. Toned is building muscle, but women get so afraid to build muscle, and I'm going to talk about this in another podcast, because they think it's going to make them bulky. That is so not true, okay? Strength training, breaking down these fibers and making them grow back stronger and bigger, is how you build muscle and increase muscle mass. That's just how you get toned. That is how you get a lean, toned body. And it's important for overall health, strength and your metabolism.
Thank you guys so much for tuning in. And don't forget, Season 2 of The WarriorBabe Show launches on February 5th. Guys, I am so excited. I cannot wait to share more engaging and insightful episodes with you all. Until then, keep listening, and I will see you on February 5th. Thank you.
Up next
Everything →
30 minWhy Isn't the Scale Moving When I Eat Well and Lift?
Episode 139 · Mar 18, 2024
30 minHow to Get Toned After 40 Without Losing More Weight
Episode 388 · Aug 17, 2026
8 minHow to Get Rid of Batwings After 40: 2 Exercises
Video · Mar 14, 2026
Best of Strength Training for Women
All 266 →
1 hr 1 minWhy Building Muscle Is Key to Aging Well After 40
With JJ Virgin
30 minWhy Am I Lifting Weights But Not Seeing Muscle?
Episode 281 · Aug 1, 2025
31 minFull Body Workouts vs Bro Splits: Which Is Better After 40?
Episode 64 · Jun 5, 2023
Free Body Transformation Assessment
Three strength sessions a week. A plan that actually fits.
No more program-hopping or punishing cardio. Tell us your schedule and where you're stuck, and we'll show you how to train for the body you want.
- Workouts built for women over 40
- Sessions that fit a real schedule
- Form and progress coached 1:1
21,800+ women transformed