The short answer
Eating 1,200 calories is often too little, not too much. Dr. Stacy Sims explains it sits around an average resting metabolic rate, so your body treats it as a threat, conserves energy and breaks down lean mass. Long-term dieting also adapts your metabolism down. Before cutting further, check your tracking is accurate.
Hear it answered
Tap play to start right where it's answered. It keeps playing while you browse.
Dr. Stacy Sims on why 1,200 calories reads as a threat and costs you lean mass
Plays from 19:38 · Ep. 250: Why a 1200-Calorie Diet Fails Women Over 40
Amber Brueseke on metabolic adaptation and why reverse dieting helps
Plays from 40:17 · Ep. 47: Why You Keep Self-Sabotaging Your Fat Loss Goals
Nikkiey on how long-term under-eating disrupts thyroid and other hormones
Plays from 13:03 · Ep. 39: How to Fix Your Metabolism After Years of Dieting
Paula Ciarniello on why tracking accuracy beats dropping to 1,200
Plays from 39:16 · Ep. 35: How to Track Macros Without Obsessing Over Every Number
The full answer
On Ep. 250, Dr. Stacy Sims explains that 1,100 to 1,200 calories is roughly what your body needs lying in bed, before you even get up to pee. Eat that little and the body conserves energy and pulls fuel from lean mass, which is metabolically active tissue. The women she sees under-eating tend to gain belly fat, look puffy, lose lean mass, stop responding to training and sleep poorly because the body is stuck in a stressed state. The same conversation runs on Eps. 300 and 324, where she adds that the menopause transition already puts the body under some stress, so feeding it and training appropriately matters even more. If you suspect hormonal or thyroid issues, that is a conversation to have with your doctor.
On Ep. 47, Amber Brueseke describes metabolic adaptation: stay in a deficit long enough and your body slows everything down to match what you feed it. Eating less and moving more doesn't break that cycle. She says metabolisms can adapt back up through reverse dieting, and that most of life should be lived at maintenance.
Nikkiey, on Ep. 39, ties long-term under-eating and overworking to shifts in leptin, ghrelin, thyroid, testosterone, progesterone, estrogen and cortisol, which in her view is why results stall even at 1,200. One sign she watches for: if you're eating 1,200 and never feel hungry, something is off. Her fix is usually bringing food back up, often a little more than you've been eating, before any cut.
There is one honest check first. On Ep. 35, Paula Ciarniello says to make sure you are logging everything, including condiments and drinks, and weighing food rather than eyeballing it. A handful of nuts can be 100 or 500 calories, and bites, licks and tastes add up. Her point: the answer is accuracy at your current intake, not dropping to 1,200. Either way, it's the plan that needs adjusting, not you.
From WarriorBabe's coaches (how we write our answers). For education, not medical advice: talk to your doctor about your own health.
Women also ask
More on Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture →
Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Is it bad to eat carbs at night?
No. On The WarriorBabe Show, Nikkiey Stott tells women over 40 to please have carbs at dinner, because that fuel helps your body repair and recover while you sleep. Guest Esther Blum adds that whole-food carbs paired with protein and fiber can calm nighttime cortisol and support sleep. Eating very close to bedtime is the one caveat.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Should I follow a bodybuilding prep diet to get lean?
Probably not, unless you actually want to compete. On Ep. 35, Paula Ciarniello explains that a contest prep diet is not a lifestyle. It takes everyday habits to an extreme most women don't want to live with. Tracking food, hitting calories and hitting protein can get you lean in a way you can enjoy, without the prep extremes.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Can you build muscle while intermittent fasting?
Yes, but it's harder, and Nikkiey doesn't think it's the best route. She explains that intermittent fasting can work for muscle if you hit your calories, prioritize protein, keep your fast to roughly the overnight hours, and train inside your eating window. Long fasts without enough protein work against muscle growth.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Do summer shred challenges actually work?
Not in the way they promise. Nikkiey explains that summer shred challenges usually rely on crash dieting, excessive cardio and severe calorie deficits. They can produce temporary results, but nobody can sustain them for months, so most women rebound to their old habits and regain the weight. Progress that lasts takes time and patience.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Do I need to detox or do a cleanse to lose weight?
No. Nikkiey explains that your liver, kidneys and digestive system already filter out and eliminate toxins, so juice cleanses and detox supplements aren't needed. Detox diets usually mean severe calorie restriction, which can lead to nutrient deficiencies, muscle loss and a slowed metabolism. A balanced diet and steady daily habits work better.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Do carbs make you gain weight?
No. Nikkiey explains that carbs on their own don't make you gain fat. Eating more calories than your body burns does, whether those calories come from carbs, fat or protein. Carbs are stored as glycogen, which holds about three grams of water per gram, so the scale can rise temporarily without any fat gain.
Read the answer →
Work out yours
All calculators →Watch or listen in full
More on this topic →
1 hr 3 minWhy a 1200-Calorie Diet Fails Women Over 40
With Dr. Stacy Sims
28 minHow to Fix Your Metabolism After Years of Dieting
Episode 39 · Apr 7, 2023
1 hr 1 minHow to Track Macros Without Obsessing Over Every Number
With Paula Ciarniello
Done with diets? Good. So are we.
21,800+ women coached
Keto, fasting, 1,200 calories, Monday restarts. You did the work, and the diets let you down. We'll help you eat in a way you can keep for life.
- No foods off-limits
- Eat more and still see results
- A plan built for the long term



