Skip to content

Video6 minWith Nikkiey Stott

Strength Training vs Cardio for Muscle Tone After 40

Chapters

This video is part ofHow to Get Toned67 lessons · where to start, common questions and more

In this video

If you've been logging miles on the treadmill, bike or pavement and your body still isn't changing shape, this video explains why. Getting toned comes from two things together: building muscle through resistance training, and lowering body fat enough for that muscle to show. Cardio helps your heart, lungs and calorie burn, but it doesn't challenge your muscles the way lifting does. Done in excess without strength training, it can even cost you muscle.

The video walks through how resistance training works, from creating small tears in muscle fibers that rebuild thicker and stronger, to why studies show it beats cardio alone for body composition. It also covers progressive overload, the role of protein, carbs and fats, and why hydration matters more than most women realize.

The bottom line: keep cardio for your heart and endurance, but make strength training the focus if a defined, strong body is what you're after, and support it with the right balance of nutrients.

Key takeaways

  • Being toned means having muscle definition, which comes from building muscle plus having a body fat level low enough for that muscle to show.
  • Even well-developed muscle won't be visible under a layer of fat, so managing body fat through diet and training matters as much as lifting.
  • Cardio is excellent for heart and lung health and burning calories, but it doesn't directly build the muscle needed for a toned look.
  • Too much cardio without strength training can lead to muscle loss, because the body may break down muscle for fuel.
  • Resistance training can use your body weight, dumbbells or bands, and studies show it is superior to cardio alone for increasing muscle and decreasing fat.
  • Apply progressive overload by gradually increasing the weight, the frequency of the exercises or the number of repetitions over time.
  • Eat protein for muscle repair, carbohydrates for workout energy and fats for hormone production, and stay hydrated to support performance and recovery.
  • More cardio isn't always better for fat loss; the right balance and intensity matters, with strength training as the focus if toning is the goal.

Questions answered

Why isn't cardio making me look toned?

Cardio raises your heart rate and burns calories, but it doesn't challenge your muscles the way resistance training does, so it's less effective at creating the muscle growth needed for definition. A toned look needs both muscle and lower body fat.

Can too much cardio make you lose muscle?

The video explains that extensive cardio can lead to muscle loss if it isn't balanced with strength training, because the body might break down muscle for fuel.

What does toned actually mean?

Toned refers to muscle definition, which comes from a combination of muscle hypertrophy, or thicker muscle fibers, and a lower body fat percentage that lets the muscle show.

Do I need heavy weights for resistance training?

No. The video says resistance can come from your body weight, dumbbells or bands, as long as your muscles are contracting against an external resistance.

How does nutrition help me get toned?

Protein supports muscle repair and growth, carbohydrates fuel your workouts and fats play a key role in hormone production. Hydration also helps move nutrients to your muscles, cool your body during exercise and support recovery.

Should I stop doing cardio completely?

No. The video recommends balancing cardio and strength training, keeping cardio for heart health and endurance while making strength training a bigger focus if toning is your goal.

Ask Nikkiey

Questions this video helps answer, with what Nikkiey says across everything WarriorBabe teaches.

  • Strength Training for Women

    Do I need to stop doing cardio to build muscle?

    No. Nikkiey says you shouldn't cut cardio completely, because your heart is a muscle and needs it too. What works against muscle is too much cardio, especially when you aren't eating enough. Do more strength training than cardio, keep cardio sessions shorter and balanced, and eat enough protein and food to fuel both.

    Read the answer →

  • Building Muscle After 40

    Can too much cardio make you lose muscle?

    Yes. Nikkiey explains that long, frequent cardio without strength training can lead your body to break down muscle tissue for fuel, which lowers muscle mass and slows your metabolism. Pair that with undereating and you sit in a catabolic state: you may weigh less, but you lose muscle and end up skinny fat instead of toned.

    Read the answer →

Full transcript

Narrator: Have you been hitting the treadmill, sweating it out on the bike, or pounding the pavement day after day to find that your body isn't shaping up the way you expected? You're not alone. Today, we're diving deep into the real reasons why cardio alone isn't the magic bullet for getting toned. Stick around to uncover some eye-opening science that will transform your fitness approach and how you think about cardio.

Let's break down what we mean when we say toned. It's one of those fitness terms that gets thrown around a lot. Technically, it refers to muscle definition, which is achieved by having a lower body fat percentage that allows your muscles to pop visually. It's not just about losing weight. It's about shaping and defining your muscles through specific types of training and nutrition strategies.

Muscle tone comes from a combination of muscle hypertrophy and low body fat. Hypertrophy is a fancy way of saying your muscle fibers are getting thicker. This happens because during resistance training, you create small tears in your muscle fibers. Your body repairs those tears, making the muscles bigger and stronger over time. However, even well-developed muscles won't show if they're covered by a layer of fat. That's why managing body fat through diet and different types of training is crucial.

Cardiovascular exercise is any physical activity that raises your heart rate and keeps it elevated for a prolonged period. It's a cornerstone of fitness for improving heart and lung health. This can include activities like brisk walking, running, cycling, or swimming. Cardio workouts are excellent for burning calories quickly and improving overall cardiovascular health. But they have limitations, especially when it comes to building muscle mass.

While cardio is effective for weight loss and has numerous health benefits, it doesn't directly contribute to muscle growth, which is essential for that toned look. Cardio primarily involves cardiovascular endurance and helps with calorie expenditure. However, because it doesn't challenge the muscles in the same way that resistance training does, it's less effective at creating the muscle growth needed for real definition. More so, extensive cardio can even lead to muscle loss if not balanced with strength training, as the body might catabolize muscle for fuel.

Resistance training, on the other hand, involves exercises that cause the muscles to contract against an external resistance with the expectation of increases in strength, tone, mass, and/or endurance. The resistance can come from your body weight, dumbbells, or bands. Unlike cardio, resistance exercises are designed to break down muscle fibers so they can rebuild stronger. Studies have repeatedly shown that resistance training is superior to cardio alone for improving body composition, that is, increasing muscle mass and decreasing fat mass.

Resistance training, such as lifting weights or body weight exercises, not only strengthens the muscles but also boosts basal metabolic rate, BMR, meaning you burn more calories even when you're not working out. This effect is enhanced by the afterburn effect, or EPOC, which significantly increases calorie expenditure post-exercise.

Nutrition is pivotal in shaping your body. Proteins are essential for muscle repair and growth, while carbohydrates provide the energy needed for your workouts. And fats are also crucial, as they play a key role in hormone production, including hormones like testosterone and growth hormone, which help with muscle growth. Getting the right balance of these nutrients can help you maximize your workouts and see better results faster.

Hydration is another critical aspect often overlooked. Water helps maintain optimal blood volume, so nutrients can move through your body and into your muscles. It's also crucial for cooling your body down during exercise and helping with muscle recovery. Proper hydration ensures that you perform at your best and achieve optimal results from your training sessions.

Balancing cardio and strength training in your fitness routine is essential for achieving a well-rounded and toned physique. Cardio is important for cardiovascular health and endurance, but it should not be the only focus if toning is the goal. Including more strength training will not only help build more muscle mass, but also ensure that you are burning calories more efficiently even while at rest.

Progressive overload is a critical concept in resistance training. It involves gradually increasing the amount of weight used, the frequency of the exercises, or the number of repetitions in your training session. This continuous challenge promotes muscle growth and strength increases over time. By systematically increasing the demand on the musculoskeletal system, you can continue to make gains in muscle size, strength, and endurance.

Let's debunk some common myths about cardio. First, more cardio isn't always better for fat loss. It's about the right balance and intensity. Second, while cardio is effective for weight management and cardiovascular health, it is not the most efficient way to achieve a toned body. Incorporating strength training into your routine is crucial for muscle definition and overall body composition improvements.

Now that you know why cardio alone won't get you that toned look you're after, and what actually will, it's time to take action. If you're ready to revamp your fitness routine and truly transform your body, check out WarriorBabe. We provide tailored fitness programs that focus on strength training and proper nutrition to help you get toned, strong, and confident. Click the link in the description below to join our community and start your journey to a more effective workout today.

Best of How to Get Toned

All 67 →

Free Body
Transformation Assessment

Apply now